Mayfly Tavern Menu

Mayfly Tavern's menu offers a delightful variety that’s sure to please everyone’s palate. Starting with the appetizers, you can’t go wrong with the Kickin' Green Beans or the Cheesy Jalapeno Pretzel, both perfect for sharing or devouring solo. If you're in the mood for something heartier, the Buffalo Shrimp and Cajun Shrimp will satisfy those spice cravings, while the Loaded Spuds hit the spot by being packed with flavor.

When it comes to handheld delights, the Classic Club and Cajun Shrimp Po'boy stand out as crowd favorites, but don’t overlook Wally's Reuben and Philly Cheesesteak for that classic satisfaction. Their burger selection also impresses, featuring mouthwatering options like the Smash Burger and BBQ Bacon Cheddar, perfect for the true burger enthusiast. Plus, the retro charm of the Old Fashioned Fried Bologna sandwich adds a nostalgic twist to your meal.

With so many tempting choices and a cozy atmosphere, Mayfly Tavern is a must-visit for anyone in Toledo. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or planning a leisurely meal, the value and quality make it hard to resist. So why not gather some friends and stop by to try a little bit of everything? You won’t be disappointed!